Which baby food has lead

These 10 baby foods have the highest levels of lead, says report

Of each of the metals, arsenic was found in 73% of baby foods, lead was found in 94%, cadmium was found in 75% and mercury was found in 32%.



STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. -- Nearly all baby foods sold in the United States include trace amounts of lead, but some contain much more of the potentially harmful metal than others.

A recent study conducted by Healthy Babies Bright Future (HBBF) found that 95% of all popular baby foods in the country contain toxic heavy metals, with 94% containing lead.

Researchers tested 168 different baby food items, consisting of 61 brands and 13 types of food, including infant formula, teething biscuits, cereals, and fruit juices, all of which were selected by parents at their local stores and online. The study tested for lead, cadmium, arsenic and mercury, with lead being, by far, the most prevalent of the group.

Of the 158 baby food items that tested positive for lead, these 10 contained the highest amount, measured in parts per billion (ppb):

  • Healthy Times Organic Brown Rice Cereal - 4+ months: 67. 4 ppb
  • SOBISK Breakfast Biscuits - Golden Oats Snack: 60.1 ppb
  • NurturMe Organic Quinoa Cereals - Quinoa + Sweet Potato + Raisin Cereal: 39.8 ppb
  • Sprout Organic Quinoa Puffs Baby Cereal Snack - Apple Kale Snack: 39.3 ppb
  • Gerber Sweet Potato - Sitter 2nd Food Veggie: 29.3 ppb
  • Beech-Nut Classics Sweet Carrots - 2: 27.2 ppb
  • Parent’s Choice (Walmart) Organic Strawberry Rice Rusks - Stage 2, 6+ months: 26.9 ppb
  • Beech-Nut Classics Sweet Potatoes - Stage 2, from about 6 months: 24.1 ppb
  • Beech-Nut Classics Sweet Carrots - Stage 2: 23.5 ppb
  • Earth’s Best Whole Grain Rice Cereal: 22.5 ppb

According to the study, lead was found in 94% of baby foods, cadmium in 75%, arsenic in 73% and mercury in 32% of foods. Twenty-six percent of baby foods contained all four metals, 40% contained three metals, 21% contained two metals, and 8% contained only one metal. Only 5% (nine baby foods) contained no metals.

These metals found in baby foods can lead to various problems for children, including IQ loss, attention deficits, and other learning and behavioral issues.

U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer is demanding new federal action by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) that would force the baby food industry to address the safety issue.

According to the study, while the FDA has proposed to limit the amount of toxic heavy metals in baby food in the past, no action has been taken.


HBBF recommended five healthier food substitutions that can help in reducing babies’ exposure to heavy toxic metals:

  • Rather than rice snacks, parents can give their children rice-free snacks, which which contain much lower levels of toxic metals.
  • Parents can use organic teething foods, like frozen bananas and chilled cucumbers, instead of teething biscuits or rice tusks.
  • Multi-grain cereals, like oatmeal, can also be fed to babies instead of rice cereal.
  • Babies can drink tap water instead of fruit juice.
  • Feed babies a variety of fruits and veggies instead of just carrots and sweet potatoes.

If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we may receive compensation.

Leading baby food manufacturers knowingly sold products with high levels of toxic metals, a congressional investigation found

CNN  — 

Four leading baby food manufacturers knowingly sold baby food that contained high levels of toxic heavy metals, according to internal company documents included in a congressional investigation released Thursday.

“Dangerous levels of toxic metals like arsenic, lead, cadmium and mercury exist in baby foods at levels that exceed what experts and governing bodies say are permissible,” said Democratic Rep. Raja Krishnamoorthi of Illinois, chair of the House Subcommittee on Economic and Consumer Policy, which conducted the investigation, signed by the Democratic members.

Krishnamoorthi said the spreadsheets provided by manufacturers are “shocking” because they show evidence that some baby foods contain hundreds of parts per billion of dangerous metals. “Yet we know that in a lot of cases, we should not have anything more than single digit parts per billion of any of these metals in any of our foods,” he told CNN.

Arsenic, lead, cadmium and mercury are in the World Health Organization’s top 10 chemicals of concern for infants and children.

As natural elements, they are in the soil in which crops are grown and thus can’t be avoided. Some crop fields and regions, however, contain more toxic levels than others, partly due to the overuse of metal-containing pesticides and ongoing industrial pollution.

“There was a time where we used metals as the predominant pesticide for many years, assuming it was safe,” said Dr. Leonardo Trasande, chief of environmental pediatrics at NYU Langone.

All of these heavy metals have been linked to cancer, chronic disease and neurotoxic effects, but it’s the devastating damage that can be done to a developing baby’s brain that makes baby food toxicity so critical.

The US Food and Drug Administration has not yet set minimum levels for heavy metals in most infant food. The agency did set a standard of 100 parts per billion inorganic arsenic for infant rice cereal, but even that level is considered much too high for baby’s safety, critics say, especially since the FDA has already set a much lower standard of 10 parts per billion of inorganic arsenic for bottled water.

From the time of conception through the age of 2, babies have an extremely high sensitivity to neurotoxic chemicals, said Jane Houlihan, the national director of science and health for Healthy Babies Bright Futures, a coalition of advocates committed to reducing babies’ exposures to neurotoxic chemicals.

“Their brain is forming rapidly, and so when they’re exposed to metals that can interrupt those natural processes, the impacts range from behavioral problems to aggression to IQ loss and all kinds of cognitive and behavioral deficits that can persist throughout life,” Houlihan said.

“Pound for pound, babies get the highest dose of these heavy metals compared to other parts of the population,” she said. “So the consequences are serious.”

Healthy Babies Bright Futures published a report in 2019 that found toxic metals in 95% of the baby foods randomly pulled off supermarket shelves and tested – that exposé was the “inspiration” for the subcommittee’s work, Krishnamoorthi told CNN.

READ MORE: New US dietary guidelines include recs for babies and toddlers for first time

Internal testing done by Gerber; Beech-Nut Nutrition Company; Nurture, Inc., which sells Happy Baby products; and Hain Celestial Group, Inc., which sells Earth’s Best Organic baby food, showed levels of heavy metals far above limits set for bottled water by the FDA and the US Environmental Protection Agency, the congressional investigators found.

Baby food ingredients in certain products contained up to 91 times the inorganic arsenic level, up to 177 times the lead level, up to 69 times the cadmium level, and up to five times the mercury level allowed in bottled water, the report said, yet the companies still approved those products for sale.

Whether the baby food was organic or not did not matter, the subcommittee found – levels of toxic metals were still high.

CNN reached out to the four companies for reaction prior to the publication of the report, which none of them had yet seen.

Gerber told CNN in an email statement, in part, “All our foods meet our safety and quality standards, which are among the strictest in not just the U.S., but the world. Gerber foods are backed up by rigorous oversight at all levels of the growing and production process. Where government standards don’t currently exist, we develop our own rigorous standards by applying the latest food safety guidance.

“As stated in our 2019 response to the Congressional Inquiry, the elements in question occur naturally in the soil and water in which crops are grown. To minimize their presence, we take multiple steps including: prioritizing growing locations based on climate and soil composition; approving fields before crops are planted based on soil testing; rotating crops according to best available science; and testing of produce, water and other ingredients.”

Beech-Nut Nutrition said it “established heavy metal testing standards 35 years ago, and we continuously review and strengthen them wherever possible. ” In addition, the company said it tested “every delivery of fruits, vegetables, rice and other ingredients for up to 255 contaminants to confirm that every shipment meets our strict quality standards. If the ingredients don’t meet our standards, we reject them.”

Happy Baby, which is part of Happy Family Organics, responded that the company “does not sell any products that have not been rigorously tested, and do not have products in-market with contaminant ranges outside of the limits set by the FDA.

“Many of the results we provided as part of this 2019 report were collected based on a small portion of our portfolio and are not representative generally of our entire range of products at-shelf today. Also, the data points include two outliers of high lead results, not replicable in our testing, but which we included for completeness and transparency.”

Hain reached out after the report published and provided the following statement: “We are disappointed that the Subcommittee report examined outdated data and does not reflect our current practices. Earth’s Best has consistently supported efforts to reduce naturally occurring heavy metals from our food supply and stands ready to assist the Subcomittee’s efforts toward that goal.”

READ MORE: How to avoid toxic metals in your baby’s food (and yours)

Three additional baby food companies, according to the congressional investigators, did not fully cooperate with the subcommittee’s investigation: Sprout Organic Foods; Walmart, which sells Parent’s Choice baby food; and Campbell Soup Company, which sells the Plum Organics brand of baby products.

“The Subcommittee is greatly concerned that their lack of cooperation might be obscuring the presence of even higher levels of toxic heavy metals in their baby food products than their competitors’ products,” the report stated.

CNN reached out via email and phone multiple times to Sprout Organic Foods and Walmart, which sells Parent’s Choice, but did not receive comments before this story published.

A Campbell spokesperson did reply: “For more than 150 years, Campbell has placed the safety of consumers, especially our youngest consumers, above all else. That is why we fully cooperated with the House Oversight Subcommittee’s baby food review. We responded quickly to their questions and never refused anything requested of us.”

The subcommittee didn’t agree with Campbell’s assessment.

“Instead of producing any substantive information, Campbell provided a spreadsheet self-declaring that every one of its products ‘meets criteria,’” the subcommittee wrote. “Campbell’s evasion is concerning, as even limited independent testing has revealed the presence of toxic heavy metals in its baby food.”

Update: Walmart provided CNN the following statement via email: “We provided information to the subcommittee nearly a year ago and invited more dialogue on this important issue but never received any additional inquiries.

“Healthy Babies Bright Futures also published ‘What’s in my baby’s food,’ in October of 2019 that tested seven Walmart private label products and according to their reported results, the metals tested were within FDA guidance levels. We will review the report now that it is available.

In response to Walmart’s statement, Better Babies Bright Futures’ health and science director, Jane Houlihan, told CNN that “the vast majority of baby foods have no FDA guidance levels.

“So it’s disingenuous for companies to say they meet guidance safety standards when there are none,” Houlihan said.

READ MORE: Pregnant women should get Covid vaccine, US doctors say, despite conflicting international advice

The subcommittee report also stated that Hain Celestial Group, Inc., maker of Earth’s Best Organic, had presented “a secret slide presentation” on August 1, 2019, to FDA regulators that revealed “increased risks of toxic heavy metals in baby foods.”

The slides showed the FDA that Hain routinely tested only the ingredients that go into their baby foods for heavy metals, and failed to test the finished product that would be sold, the report said.

Yet in “100% of the Hain baby foods tested, inorganic arsenic levels were higher in the finished baby food than the company estimated they would be based on individual ingredient testing. Inorganic arsenic was between 28% and 93% higher in the finished products,” the subcommittee wrote.

“This presentation made clear that ingredient testing is inadequate, and that only final product testing can measure the true danger posed by baby foods.”

Hain sent CNN this response: “The meeting was not ‘secret’ – we provided the document to the Subcommittee to be helpful. The purpose of the meeting was to determine a path forward to expand our testing program to include more raw ingredients and reduce the overall level of metals in our finished product.

“Following the meeting, we took several steps to reduce the levels of heavy metals in our finished products – including no longer using brown rice in our products that are primarily rice based, changing other ingredients and conducting additional testing of finished product before shipping.

READ MORE: Antibiotic use in babies linked to allergies, asthma and other conditions, study finds

The FDA under the Trump administration took no new action in response to the presentation, the investigation found: “To this day, baby foods containing toxic heavy metals bear no label or warning to parents. Manufacturers are free to test only ingredients, or, for the vast majority of baby foods, to conduct no testing at all.”

CNN reached out to the FDA with a set of detailed questions about these issues raised by the report and received the following statement.

The FDA said, in part, “Sampling of infant rice cereal showed that since 2016 manufacturers have made significant progress in reducing arsenic in infant rice cereal products, demonstrating that this action level is achievable by industry.

“Going forward,” the FDA said, “good manufacturing processes, such as sourcing rice and other ingredients with lower inorganic arsenic levels, will continue to help manufacturers produce infant rice cereal with inorganic arsenic levels below the action level.”

An FDA official later told CNN the agency is currently reviewing the subcommittee report’s findings.

READ MORE: Worried about your toddler right now? Take a deep breath

Nurture (Happy Baby): Of the four companies who were part of the investigation, only Nurture tested the final product – the actual food babies would eat – after all ingredients had been added.

Internal documents from Nurture show that the company set a goal threshold of 100 parts per billion for inorganic arsenic in its final baby food product. Listed next to that goal was the actual level of arsenic found in the food.

Despite the fact that arsenic levels in the products routinely tested over the stated goal – 120 parts per billion, 130 parts per billion, 160 parts per billion, even as much as 180 parts per billion, the documents showed Nurture continued to mark the products as ready to sell.

Levels of lead, cadmium and mercury were often high as well, the subcommittee report said. Documents showed Nurture sold Happy Baby baby foods that tested as high as 500 parts per billion and 641 parts per billion for lead.

Nurture also sold “a finished baby food product that contained 10 ppb (parts per billion) mercury, and two others that contained 9. 8 and 7.3 ppb (parts per billion). A level of 10 ppb (parts per billion) is five times more than the EPA’s 2 ppb (parts per billion) standard for drinking water,” the subcommittee wrote.

Hain (Earth’s Best Organic): Hain, along with Gerber and Beech-Nut, did not test its final products, the subcommittee found.

Instead, Hain tested various ingredients it added to the final product – such as cinnamon, blueberry puree and a mix of vitamins used to boost nutrient levels called a “vitamin pre-mix,” that tested at 223 parts per billion for inorganic arsenic.

No level of lead is safe for children, according to the American Academy of Pediatrics, yet Hain used ingredients containing as much as 352 parts per billion lead, internal documents showed.

When it came to cadmium, Hain used some 102 ingredients that tested over 20 parts per billion cadmium – a few tested much higher, up to 260 parts per billion cadmium. There are no documents that illustrate the levels of mercury in Hain’s Earth’s Best Organic baby foods, as the company does not test for it.

Beech-Nut baby foods: Beech-Nut made baby food with ingredients that tested as “high as 913.4 ppb (parts per billion) arsenic,” the investigation found, including an additive for “crumb softness” that contained up to 710.90 parts per billion arsenic.

Beech-Nut also used “many ingredients with high lead content, including 483 that contained over 5 ppb (parts per billion) lead,” the subcommittee wrote.

Cadmium levels should not exceed 5 parts per billion in drinking water, according to the FDA, yet Beech-Nut had some ingredients that reached levels of 344.55 parts per billion. Like Hain, Beech-Nut does not test for mercury.

Gerber baby foods: Gerber only tests ingredients, not the final product, the subcommittee said. Some of the ingredients used in making Gerber baby food, such as “conventional sweet potatoes,” tested as high as 48 parts per billion lead.

Internal documents also showed the baby food giant used high-arsenic ingredients, the subcommittee said, “including 67 batches of rice flour that had tested over 90 ppb (parts per billion) inorganic arsenic.

The company rarely tests for mercury, the subcommittee said, but cadmium levels in 75% of Gerber carrots exceeded the recommended 5 parts per billion, with some reaching up to 87 parts per billion, the report said.

READ MORE: ‘Shades of Black’ and other toddler books celebrate black families

The subcommittee report was clear on what should be done. Instead of setting limits for one food at a time, the FDA should standardize maximum levels for each toxic metal that can damage a baby’s developing brain and apply them to all foods.

There should be mandatory testing of any baby food product before it hits the shelves, the subcommittee recommended. Manufacturers should no longer be allowed to simply test ingredients.

Substitutes should be found for any ingredients over recommended limits, and if that cannot happen, then the food or ingredient should not be used in baby food, the subcommittee said. Take rice, for example, which is a primary source of inorganic arsenic exposure for babies.

“Every maker of baby food … is on notice that we in Congress are not going to sit back and accept the status quo anymore,” Krishnamoorthi said.

“I hope that companies would voluntarily start to undertake actions such as testing their food more properly and thoroughly and phase out certain ingredients that we know are problematic right now,” he said.

“But I’m also being realistic. We need legislation to compel compliance with standards that the FDA needs to develop.”

CNN’s Megan Marples contributed to this report.

Baby food is a new hobby for adults in the West


Hollywood stars have created a fashion for baby food. Lady Gaga, Jennifer Aniston, Reese Witherspoon and Cheryl Cole say they managed to lose weight thanks to such an unusual diet.

In the UK, the craze led to a 20 percent increase in puree sales and a 59 percent increase in purchases of powdered baby food.

Indeed, the advertised celebrity diet is to blame. Experts say that in principle this approach can contribute to weight loss, but you should not forget about training if you want to lose up to ten kilograms of weight in six weeks. nine0003

It's no secret that baby food has restrictions on the content of salt, sugar, and is subject to stricter control. Approximately one package of baby food contains from 100 to 120 kilocalories.

Nutritionists state: diet is not particularly capable of harming human health, however, those who want to lose weight should eat right and adhere to the training regimen .

The British Dietetic Association advises people to grow up and turn their attention to carrots and apples instead of baby food, according to Pedpresa. nine0003

Yaroslav Plutenko


Other news in this section:

  • FrutoKids brand presents sausages for kids
  • We are approaching the holiday together with New Year's gifts from FrutoNyanya
  • Introducing the baby to legumes: "Lentil soup puree" from "FrutoNyanya"
  • A mix of tasty and healthy in one jar: FrutoNyanya puree with a new banana-cookie-yoghurt flavor in 250 g format
  • Immuno Baby from FrutoNyanya for babies from 8 months

Tags: children food , stars , diet , training

Related articles:

Depot WPF has developed a package for the new line of "Nappies"

From birth to the stars

Baby food with arsenic

What is good and what is bad? Law and business ethics in the baby food industry

Rastishka with seeds

Agusha became the best food for children

Latest food news:

  • 00:41 Sparkling debut in Coffeemania restaurants
  • 00:37 Opening of the Italian restaurant in Sochi
  • 00:32 Level Kitchen launches fishless menu
  • 00:26 Chief Santa Claus in Anderson!
  • 09:20 Winter drink collection at Coffeemania
  • 09:10 The best sparkling wine of the author's guide Artur Sargsyan was "Imperial" Vintage Brut 2017 from "Abrau-Durso"
  • 09:02 Kaluga "Kristall" applied to the Federal Antimonopoly Service for "Jägermeister"
  • nine0028 12:04 Boris Titov: "In 10 years, Russian winemaking has become fundamentally different, both in quantity and quality"
  • 22:35 Seasonal menu at the Barrel
  • 22:24 Jokes are over: what is the danger of being overweight?
  • 12:13 New Year's collection of coffeemania desserts
  • 23:06 Gastronomic dinner at Cevicheria
  • 11:22 Festive dishes to order in the restaurant "Matryoshka"
  • 11:07 The Nest bar and jewelry brand LAV'Z are the perfect couple in New Year's collaboration
  • 10:57 Caramel New Year in Anderson!

see previous


Ideal Diet for Arthritis

One of the most common questions people with arthritis ask is, "Is there a special diet for arthritis?" Although miraculous. ..


report news

Most read on this topic:

"Rastishka" with seeds

Fats in modern infant formula: myths and reality

Healthy can be tasty

Favorite treats for children with the necessary set of vitamins 9 are on sale0003

A book about baby food from complementary foods up to 3 years has been published

Agusha "I myself!" with banana and biscuits

We invite you to take part in the competition of journalistic works "PROPER NUTRITION - A HEALTHY FUTURE"

Pregnant and lactating Muscovites will receive fruit rations

New NESTLÉ baby cereals in portion packs

Syria bans croissants

Choose orthopedic slippers


Pie tatin with peaches and cranberries
Banana tatin pie
Tart tatin with apricots
Pie tatin with peaches
Pie tatin with plums and grapes
Pie tatin with pears
Tatin pie with pineapple
Mango tatin pie


Honey massage for the buttocks
Top 20 Products for Effective Fitness
Office fitness. Dedicated to the victims of sedentary work
grape seeds for hair growth
Five fitness myths
Adolescent skin and nutrition
Food for hair growth
Food for healthy hair. Hair Composition


Honey massage for buttocks


Anti-aging products

Nutrition for young athletes

Food for strong nails

The most pleasant exercise. What muscles do we pump during sex?

About products for beautiful breasts

What Foods Help Enlarge Breasts?

Penitentiary diet - Newspaper Kommersant No. 232 (5982) dated 12/14/2016

1K 3 2 minutes. ... nine0003

Social activists ask Anna Kuznetsova, commissioner for children's rights under the President of the Russian Federation, to pay attention to the nutrition of children born in places of deprivation of liberty. As an example, they cited a colony-settlement in the Krasnoyarsk Territory, where perishable foods were replaced with milk and juice in the diet for pregnant and lactating women, and juices, purees and cereals for children appeared only after letters to the prosecutor's office.

Photo: Dmitry Korotaev, Kommersant / buy photo

A letter with a request to pay attention to the "problem of children born in places of deprivation of liberty, especially in regions remote from Moscow" was sent to Anna Kuznetsova and the all-Russian public movement "Mothers of Russia" by the head of the public organization "Institute for Problems of Modern Society" Olga Kiyutsina . She was approached by relatives of convicts from colony-settlement N48 near the village of Kurdoyaki, 350 km from Krasnoyarsk. There are six pregnant women and 31 women with children under three years old in the colony. "The relatives of the convicts said that in KP-48 there are problems with food for pregnant women, lactating women and children. In response to my requests, the Federal Penitentiary Service of the Krasnoyarsk Territory said that they were making substitutions in food, since the colony is far away in the taiga," she said. Kommersant Olga Kiyutsina. “My wife didn’t have enough milk to feed the child, because they didn’t feed normally. Now in the colony she is given two packs of ready-made formula, but this is not enough,” the husband of one of the convicts in KP-48 told Kommersant. asking not to use his last name. He noted that children older than a year were given juices, mashed potatoes and cereals after the letters that Olga Kiyutsina began sending to supervisory authorities. nine0003

The Federal Penitentiary Service of the Russian Federation replied to Olga Kiyutsina (all answers are at the disposal of the editors) that children's meals are organized in accordance with the norms for orphanages, which are defined in the letter of the Ministry of Health and Social Development of the Russian Federation dated August 10, 2006 N15-3 / 1295-04. However, from the main department of the Federal Penitentiary Service for the Krasnoyarsk Territory, Ms. Kiyutsina received a letter stating that the children are being fed in accordance with the decision of the Council of Administration of the Krasnoyarsk Territory dated June 26, 2006 N226-p. The regional department indicated that "due to the territorial remoteness of the institution from regional centers and the difficulties of delivering perishable products - cheese, sour cream, milk, fresh fruit, milk and juice are being replaced in accordance with the norms for replacing some food products with others, Appendix N7 of Order of the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation dated 26 February 2016 N48". The regional department of the Federal Penitentiary Service reports that "food is given out every five days, and milk every day." “We checked. Not a single regulatory act provides for the replacement of cheese and sour cream with milk. And the possibility of replacing products for children is generally excluded.

Learn more